Thursday, 6 May 2010

Things Should've Got A Lot Better?

Election day is upon us, so it only seems right to have a quick retrospective look at New Labour before the face of British politics is changed forever...again.

Like anyone with a heart, who was not a Thatcherite idiot-savant that is, the morning of 2nd May 1997 was a very good day. On the 1st May I had cast my vote for Vernon Coaker and for the first time since 1983 we had a Labour MP in an area with a long history of voting Tory. 

And what exactly have New Labour achieved in their long residency at Number 10?

Their numerous accomplishments remain, for me, dwarfed by the cruel debacle of the illegal war in Iraq and the humiliating period of 2001-07, where Tony Blair acted as some kind of toothy lap dog to the retarded, Ivy League, monkey king pretender to the world's most powerful country. Iraq looms large, mainly for the huge loss of civilian life, never mind the raft of US and UK military causalities and for what exactly? Talk of war crimes and illegality has faded it seems but in my mind it remains incredibly strong.

Iraq is the distorting lens that leaves much of what the Labour party has achieved looking asinine and pyrrhic but there is much there to celebrate. The social-morality landscape of Britain has changed a great deal, some of this may merely be down to humanity's progress but Labour enacted much legislation to enable positive social reforms for women, ethnic minorities and the gay community; civil partnerships were a thing of dreams for many but now are a crucial reality and a stepping stone to the end of discrimination as we know it. Labour must be thanked for such steps.

Of course, New Labour's vision for electoral reform has not gone as far as I would've hoped but they moved in the right direction, with the House of Lords in better shape and reform ready, the FOI act passed and devolutionary powers to Wales and Scotland. Northern Ireland and the current peace are also one of Labour's huge successes, although I do acknowledge it took numerous other parties, agencies and individuals to work together to achieve the situation we have now and although by no means perfect, I am old enough to remember the IRA as a very real threat on the UK mainland and acts of violence and terror a depressing and seemingly regular occurrence.

I am unashamed to say that, although I will not be voting for him, I believe Gordon Brown to be one of our finest chancellors and his stewardship of the UK economy and the measures he took created a far more equal society (the minimum wage being one of New Labour's finest achievements, along with the creation of an independent Bank of England), with a genuine effort to reduce poverty, consistently low unemployment and enabling a move away from crash and burn economics; rather spoilt admittedly by the global financial crisis.

The endless money pit that is our public services have also been transformed and heavily (perhaps too heavily) invested in, so that we are blessed with new schools, hospitals and facilities for social governance, such as Job Centres, Health Centres and Connexions Centres for young people. NHS waiting times have plummeted from 21 weeks under the Tories in 1997 to around 6 weeks as of now and previous lows at around 4 weeks in 2007.

As someone who used to work with young mothers, the impact of Sure Start cannot be underestimated, and neither should improvements to YOT teams and YIP projects and the transformation of the cranky and dusty old Careers Service into the young person friendly and focused Connexions.

And with regards to the industry I work in, let us not forget that the arts, dying under Thatcher and Major, has been rejuvenated, albeit with a clever and helpful dose of gambling money, which has marginally silenced the right-wing hectoring of what tax payers money is being spent on but rather, quite bizarrely, what gambler's money is being spent on...

In the minus column, aside from the crippling blow of Iraq, is the fact that when New Labour came to power in 1997 some 5 million 'working adults' were subsidised by the state and this figure remains unmoved today and for all the racist arguments of 'immigrants stealing our jobs', they have in reality filled a gap which UK citizens were unwilling to fill. The re-jigging of the benefits system has failed cut down on elements of institutionalised family state subsidy, whilst managing to demonise other claimants. A lose-lose.

A huge negative about Labour was their endless infringements upon human rights and civil liberties, under the overarching catch-all theme of the War on Terror (Copyright. Trademark. All Rights Reserved), which enabled them to pass some awful legislation that is only softened, in my mind, by the fact that Tories would've been far, far worse.

Another downside for me has been the explosion, under Labour, of bureaucratic middle-men agencies, the worst of which are the Regional Development Agencies, monoliths that entrap large swathes of government funding and then deal it out, whilst themselves costing a bloody fortune.

Finally and whilst speaking of bureaucracy, education is another sector I've worked in and has suffered terribly under New Labour. Whether it be the vulgar league table (a blight on many of our public services and a device that only ever leads to fixing the figures), SATS, paperwork of teachers and the ever increasing obsession with the GCSE as a measuring device for our children, whilst harder to measure subjects are sacrificed at the alter of 5 A-C's.

And the perverse, schizoid drive by Labour to increase participation in higher education by opening up glorified sixth form colleges as universities offering God awful subjects, whilst simultaneously bringing in tuition fees, swinging cuts to the grants systems and saddling graduates with huge student loan debts; is one of the biggest errors of its tenureship.

So yes, things should've have got a lot better under New Labour but let us not forget that they did achieve a great deal and more importantly, that the Conservatives would've been so very much worse...



  1. The Question Could Also Be Asked, what would Britain be like now had The Conservatives won in 1997?
    I have a crashing hangover today! I wont be voting until Teatime!

  2. Eh, I wrote a similar piece on my blog and then deleted it. The thing is in this country too many people are quick to moan about their lot. "We want change!" they bleat. Change to what exactly? What exactly has a Conservative government done for our country?

    Under the last Conservative government our industries were destroyed, British Steel and our mining industries pillaged, our rail network privatised, energy companies the same put under the yoke of generating profit and pushing up prices instead of serving our country. The NHS was underfunded, so were our schools, our libraries, the very social fabric of our society.

    Clause 28, the poll tax, fat cats making more money out of scams like the Westland Helicopter scandal which makes the expenses furore look like the Teddy Bear's picnic. Thatcher taught us that greed was good. She sold of the cheap council houses, made us all lust after our own property in the "right to buy" scheme, pusing up rental prices in the process. The debt bubble we have today can be traced back to those times.

    Thatcher destroyed our society and I believe a Conservative government will carry on that work. For under David Cameron, VAT will rise to 20%, interest rates will rise giving reward to those with big money in the bank, but crucifying us mortgage payers making ends meet. Cuts, cuts, cuts...back to hospital wings being closed down, hospital waiting lists shooting up, libraries gone, school falling in to disrepair. But wait, you can govern yourselves, so when all this goes tits up David Cameron can turn around and blame the mismanagement on you. You failed, not me. I gave you power and you fucked it up. So be warned of that future and vote Tory at your peril.

    I personally don't see the Iraq War as a minus. I'm one of those folks who believe Tony Blair when he makes his stand. I think the intelligence services have a lot to answer for and I wonder who is manipulating who. I'm one of those folks who gets bored of "human rights" and "civil liberties" because people who spout such guff usually just want to use their "human rights" and "civil liberties" to act like a pratt. It's the same mentality that means our children can't play in playgrounds in case their parents sue the council for injuries and means that if an asthmatic child collapses at school, teachers can't save them because they aren't allowed to touch said stricken pupil just in case they infringe their human rights. Of course, I blame the EU for all of this. I preferred the old days when we fell over or hurt ourselves we just said "Whoops-a-daisy! I'll be more careful next time!" rather than having "WeSue'Em4U" on speed dial of their mobile phone.

    Every single Liberal Democrat I've ever come across as been the most piss-weak, wishy-washy, MOR (that's middle of the road), undecided, safe as houses, change like the weather, self-serving son-of-a-bitch. Anyone who votes Lib-Dem can come to me for a bitch slap later. You have no idea what damage those people will inflict on the country. But they stand for nothing. They have no ideology. They aren't a political force born from struggle. They are the gurning middle-classes, the party for those who like to play it safe. So fuck 'em. And fuck 'em for putting Charles Kennedy out to dry (literally) - any respect I had for that party disappeared when the crucified the only human being in Parliament.

    But when you cut me, my blood doesn't run blue, or yellow or green. It runs red, so my vote will be warm and wet and straight from the heart.

    The important thing is to vote, innit? Remember, people died so you can do your duty today...and that is doubly important for you ladies out there too. Do it - you knows it makes sense.

    Over and out.

  3. "some of this may merely be down to humanity's progress "

    Humanity has made no progress. If it had, there would be no worries about a return to power for the Tories, nor would America have ever tolerated their Ivy League Monkey King as long as they did (great phrase, by the way) and Rupert Mordoch would have been run back to Australia on an underwater rail. People still suck. Maybe they suck marginally less than they used to, but it's pretty much two baby steps forward, one toddle step back, and the last few decades have seemed pretty backwards moving to me.
    Here's hoping it doesnt take eight years, your national reputation and a trillion or two dollars worth of debt for y'all to figure out (again) that conservatives running things are a bad idea.

  4. Love the hate tree thingy. The moral of the story is bring on PR asap. Ain't gonna work on Maggie's Farm no more...

  5. I'm too depressed to respond in kind, Darren has it down man, he has it down, well said brother!


Please do not be under the misapprehension that this blog has a laissez-faire comments policy where commenters can get away with whatever they want to say on account of their ‘freedom of speech’.

Blurred Clarity has a stringent comments policy. So anything off-topic, diversionary, trollish, abusive, misogynist, racist, homophobic or xenophobic will be deleted.

Cheers duckies.